Sunday, March 24, 2019

Talent or Character: A Career Paradox?



“Talent get you in the door, but character keeps you in the room!” Pretty wise words by leadership expert John Maxwell. But in the fast-paced world of the new digital economy, what wins? In my work with established professionals and leaders, I often think out loud about what matters most to them and their employers.  

A recent whitepaper by the Business Higher Education Forum reveals startling trends and facts about the types of jobs that are emerging in the digital economy and the skill-sets that will be in demand. The researchers discovered that, yes, technical Digital Building Block skills such as managing and analyzing data, programming, and cyber security will be in high demand. But there are two other skill areas will be critical: Business Enabling skills such as project management, digital design, and other business processes will be needed to operationalize digital solutions. Leadership skills which the researchers call soft or “human” skills focus on communication, critical thinking, collaboration, analytical skills and creativity are also incredibly important. Trust me, there is nothing soft about solid leadership!

The researchers went on to point out that individuals that possess at least some baseline competencies in all three areas even though they may excel in two enjoy higher job mobility as well as higher earning potential. Further, such balanced individuals are incredible competitive and much sought after for more senior, C-Suite roles. Finally, the sheer number of job opportunities that require these three areas will be staggering!

Both Digital Building Blocks and Business Enabling skills focus on talent, however, Leadership skills are solidly grounded in character. In David Brooks compelling book, The Road to Character, he contends that character is the foundation for any success in life. Those without it eventually become victim to their lack of virtue and self-discipline. Character, however, can be developed and grown which is the good news. The bad news is that it takes a lot of work.

So now that I have made the case of for the need of both talent and character, how do we demonstrate to our teams or even future employers that we have both?

Focus on Self AND Others
Many leadership programs these days involve a “Working on Self” focus through assessments, mindfulness, and other interventions. Now you may be thinking “What’s wrong with that?” On balance nothing as long as there IS a balance of using those tools to add value to others! Leadership in its purest sense is OTHER directed though not always other oriented. You can and should do the important internal work but eventually you have to lead on, for, or toward something involving some ones!

Focus on what’s Relevant versus What’s Recent
Far too often we do not realize our own transferrable skills. In fact, the researchers from the report above state that the majority of job applicants do not list the skills they have in the three domains even though they clearly have them or used them at one time. The biggest mistake that applicants (and many hiring managers) make is deciding that earlier experience is not valid experience. Nothing can be further from the truth especially in light of the fact that many of the jobs we had earlier in our careers required us to be the “doers” of many of the processes captured in these domains.

Focus on the Future
You can always learn new techniques or skills through a course or a certification program. There are many on-the-job opportunities to learn the digital building blocks needed to thrive in the ever-evolving economy. There are many free on-line courses and other continuing education opportunities available that are very cost effective. While you are spinning up the technical skills continue to build the Character Muscles as author Jim Loehr calls them. Character comes from doing the hard things, the inconvenient things, or the unpopular things NOW so that your reputation for the future is impeccable.  

So back to the original question, does talent trump character? You certainly need both but think about how you would prefer the people working with or for you? What are you willing to train someone on and how do you want them to come already “factory equipped”? I would wager you are happy to train team members on the technical skills but you would expect them to already have a strong moral and character center. 

David Brooks goes on to share that as human beings we are much like “crooked timber” and it should be our primary ambition to smooth out the rough spots and wood knots. After that, everything is gravy!

As always if I can help you and the people you associate with Get Better, Be Ready and LEAD OUT LOUD, I invite you to contact me.

Yours in leadership,

Bill Faulkner
Independent Coach, Speaker, and Trainer with the John Maxwell Team TM

Email = bill@outloudinc.com
Visit our website at: www.outloudinc.com
For more information on the John Maxwell Team, please visit

Feel free to “LIKE” our FB Page www.facebook.com/outloudinc

No comments:

Post a Comment